I found a used Ford Flex online. Looks pretty swank. Comparable price to what we paid for our Escape. Almost identical fuel economy, despite actually being a bigger vehicle (seats 7, which we usually wouldn't need, but would be good when my wife's parents are in town).
It's sold by the place that advertises as being the place to go when you can't get credit, which is a bit sketchy, but we'd be paying cash anyway, since we'll have the insurance payout and some money in our savings.